Minister of Health’s Decision that JAMP is not a “Second Person” Was Reasonable
In its new drug submission for SIMLANDI, a biosimilar containing adalimumab, JAMP Pharma Corporation (“JAMP”) sought approval for three specific presentations: (i) 40 mg/0.4 mL pre-filled syringe; (ii) 40 mg/0.4 mL auto-injector pen; and (iii) 80 mg/0.8 mL pre-filled syringe.
Given that AbbVie did not market the equivalent presentations of HUMIRA (adalimumab) in Canada, in a comprehensive and detailed decision, the Minister of Health (the “Minister”) determined that JAMP was not a “second person” for purposes of subsection 5(1) of the Patented Medicines (Notice of Compliance) Regulations (the “PM(NOC) Regulations”) and was thus not required to address patents listed on the patent register by AbbVie before being issued a Notice of Compliance (“NOC”).
Subsequently, the Minister issued an NOC to JAMP for its three presentations of SIMLANDI.
In AbbVie Corporation et al. v. The Minister of Health and JAMP Pharma Corporation, 2022 FC 1209, Justice Fothergill of the Federal Court dismissed AbbVie’s applications to judicially review the Minister’s decisions, on the basis that the Minister’s decisions were reasonable.
Justice Fothergill observed that the “PM(NOC) Regulations are closely connected with the Minister’s functions, and the Minister has great expertise in their application and interpretation”.
In summary, Justice Fothergill determined that the “Minister’s interpretation of s 5(1) of the PM(NOC) Regulations as applying only to a version of a drug that has a specific drug identification number [DIN] and that is marketed in Canada was reasonable, particularly considering the statutory objective of providing a patent enforcement mechanism only in relation to products that are in fact available to Canadians”.
Authors
Expertise
Insights
-
Intellectual Property Litigation
Rise of Trademark Phishing Scams
There has been a reported surge in trademark phishing scams. The Canadian Intellectual Property Office (“CIPO”) issued a statement warning of an email phishing scam targeting members of the public by… -
Intellectual Property Litigation
The Return of the Honda Element?
A few recent patent applications reveal that the Honda Element may be making its return to the automotive industry: The first patent application is a “camper for a vehicle”. The second… -
Intellectual Property Litigation
"Worldle" Faces a Wordle Hurdle
Kory McDonald, the creator of “Worldle”, a geography-themed game, is advocating on behalf of all games ending in “-le”. Worldle shows a series of Google Street view images from which players… -
Intellectual Property Litigation
Not a “Success Kid”
Steve King, the former Iowa Republican Congressman, has reportedly lost his appeal attempting to overturn a copyright verdict for using the “Success Kid” meme in his 2020 campaign. The “Success… -
Intellectual Property Litigation
Alaska Airlines Not Soaring After Losing Appeal
Alaska Airlines (“Alaska”) recently lost an appeal over a trademark licensing agreement at the Court of Appeal in London, in a decision favoring Virgin Group. Alaska was ordered to pay approximately… -
Intellectual Property Litigation
X’s Lawsuit Regarding Data Scraping Dismissed
A federal judge in California reportedly dismissed a lawsuit for breach-of-contract and tort claims brought by Elon Musk’s X, formerly known as Twitter, against Bright Data, in a case involving data…