Changes to Broadcasting Act will Require Online Streamers to Support the Canadian Broadcasting System
This week, Canadian Heritage Minister Steven Guilbeault introduced Bill C-10 (the “Bill”) to amend the Broadcasting Act. The proposed changes would bring online streaming services, such as Netflix, Amazon and Spotify, under domestic broadcasting regulation and may require them to, among other things, make expenditures to support Canadian audio or audio-visual programs. This could potentially include funding for programs created and produced by Canadian minority groups and serving minority populations such as Indigenous and Francophone consumers.
If passed, the Bill would give the Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission (CRTC) the power to: (i) decide which streaming services to regulate; (ii) require and determine any financial contributions to be made by these services, and (ii) regulate the discoverability of Canadian programs on streaming platforms. Failure to comply with the CRTC’s orders could lead to monetary penalties. While not contained in the Bill, the government indicated that a future policy direction to the CRTC may instruct the CRTC to ‘revisit how it defines Canadian programs for the purposes of broadcasting regulatory obligations’.
Some of the proposed changes are based on recommendations by the Broadcasting and Telecommunications Legislative Review Panel (the “Panel”), which reviewed Canada’s broadcasting laws and published 97 recommendations in its final report released in January 2020.1 The Panel rejected a so-called “Netflix tax” (i.e., charging consumers an extra levy on subscriptions to such streaming services as Netflix) and instead recommended that streaming services with access to the Canadian market contribute a percentage of their Canadian-derived revenues to fund Canadian programs.2 Aligned with the Panel’s recommendations, the Bill proposes to classify internet streaming services as “online undertakings” under the Broadcasting Act. This classification would bring them into the regulatory system that currently only imposes “Canadian content” financial contribution requirements on traditional Canadian “broadcasting undertakings”.
Canada’s Liberal government has a minority in the House of Commons. For the Bill to pass into law, the government will need the support of other Canadian political parties in Parliament. The New Democratic Party is expected to support the proposed legislation.
The Liberal government indicated it projects streaming services could contribute $830 million in additional funding to Canadian television and music production by 2023, if the Bill is passed.3 This projection assumes the CRTC will require online broadcasters to contribute to Canadian content at a similar rate as traditional broadcasters. However, the government also acknowledged that the CRTC, as the independent regulator, will determine whether and how online undertakings are required to contribute, and the form of those contributions.
Minister Guilbeault indicated he hopes the Bill is passed quickly so the CRTC can begin to determine how to implement the new regulatory framework. Minister Guilbeault intends to recommend that the Governor in Council (i.e., the Canadian cabinet) issue a directive to the CRTC requesting the CRTC implement the new framework within nine months.4 This is an aggressive timeline given the various legislative and procedural processes required for implementation.
Mixed Reaction to the Bill
Not surprisingly, reaction to the Bill by leading industry players has been mixed. Some critics are concerned the proposed legislation is too onerous and may alienate international streaming services. Others noted the Bill gives broad powers to the CRTC, but fails to provide details regarding the range of monetary penalties and the mechanism of collecting and distributing financial contributions from online streaming services.
The Canadian Media Producers Association (CMPA), the Coalition for the Diversity of Cultural Expressions (CDCE) (comprised of more than 40 organizations including ACTRA, DGC and SOCAN), and the Writers Guild of Canada, are among several key players in the Canadian film and television industry that fully support the Bill. On the other hand, The Friends of Canadian Broadcasting, a lobby group that promotes Canadian content, says the proposed Bill does not go far enough to protect “Canadian content” and domestic production.5 Bell Media, CBC, Corus Entertainment, and Rogers Sports & Media, are withholding comment until they have completed reviewing the Bill.
A Netflix representative said it “remained committed to being a good partner to Canada’s creative community while also investing in local economies”.6 Google noted it approves the choice to exclude video games and user-generated content, such as videos on YouTube, from the proposed framework.7
Looking Forward
If the Bill passes, the next steps will involve the issuance of a policy direction by the government to the CRTC to ‘guide its use of the new tools afforded by the Bill’, as well as a series of proceedings conducted by the CRTC with relevant stakeholders. Once those proceedings are concluded, the CRTC will then determine precisely how the new regulatory regime for “online undertakings” will work, who will be part of the new system, and who will be exempt. Most importantly, the CRTC will define the nature of the financial or other contributions by the online streamers to the Canadian broadcasting system and the new definition of a “Canadian program”. Stay tuned!
1 Broadcasting and Telecommunications Legislative Review, Canada’s Communications Future: Time to Act, Final Report (January 2020).
2 Ibid at 13.
3 Bill Curry and Janice Dickson, “Broadcasting bill targets online streaming services”, The Globe and Mail (4 November 2020).
4 Ibid.
5 Jordan Pinto, “Industry reacts to proposed Broadcasting Act update”, Playback (4 November 2020).
6 The Canadian Press, “Feds propose changes to Broadcasting Act that may raise $800 million from streamers”, Tri-City News (3 November 2020).
7 The Globe and Mail, supra note 3.
Expertise
Authors
Insights
-
Entertainment
Ask an Expert: Key risks and considerations relevant to performers who are active on social media, Performers Magazine
In a recent article for ACTRA Toronto's Performers Magazine, Tara Parker and Megan Brooks discuss the considerations performers should weigh before posting something to a public-facing… -
Entertainment
Canada launches public consultation on Generative AI and Copyright Law
On October 12, 2023, Canada’s Minister of Innovation, Science and Industry and its Minister of Canadian Heritage launched a public consultation on the implications of generative artificial… -
Entertainment
So You Want To Produce In Canada, Eh?
If you are considering producing in Canada, there’s a lot you not only need to know, but want to know. Why? Because it can save you both time and money - and who doesn’t want that? The discussion… -
Entertainment
CRTC Announces Three-Phased Public Consultation Plan to Implement the Online Streaming Act in Canada
On May 8, 2023, the Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission (CRTC) unveiled its three-phased regulatory plan (the “Regulatory Plan”) to consult with the public to implement the… -
Entertainment
The Online Streaming Act: Canada Passes New Legislation to Regulate Online Streaming Services
On April 27, 2023, Bill C-11, titled the Online Streaming Act (the “Act”), was passed by the Canadian Senate and received Royal Assent, officially becoming law in Canada. The Act is designed to… -
Technology
U.S. District Court Finds NBA Top Shot Moments may be Subject to U.S. Securities Laws
On May 12, 2021, a class action law suit was filed against Dapper Labs, Inc. in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York (the “Court”) alleging that Dapper Labs violated U.S…
Featured Work
-
Shareholder Activism
Board of the Toronto Lawn Club proxy defense
Goodmans LLP represented the Board of the Toronto Lawn Club in connection with the successful defense of a proxy contest against a group of concerned members… -
Mergers and Acquisitions
Screaming Eagle merges with Lionsgate Studios
Goodmans LLP acted for Screaming Eagle Acquisition Corp. in connection with its merger with the Studio Business of Lionsgate Entertainment Corp., comprised of its Television Studio and Motion Picture… -
Tax
Cineplex announces comprehensive refinancing plan
Goodmans LLP is acting for Cineplex Inc., a leading Canadian entertainment and media company, in connection with its announcement of a comprehensive refinancing plan to improve financial flexibility… -
Mergers and Acquisitions
Cineplex Inc.'s Player One Amusement Solutions business acquired by OpenGate Capital
Goodmans LLP acted for Cineplex Inc., a Canadian entertainment and media company, in connection with OpenGate Capital acquiring the amusement solutions business of Cineplex… -
Entertainment
Representing Shaftesbury Inc.
Goodmans LLP represents Shaftesbury Inc., a leading Canadian producer of scripted productions including the well-known and popular TV programs “Murdoch Mysteries," “Frankie Drake Mysteries," “Hudson… -
Entertainment
Launch of Blink49 Studios Inc.
Goodmans LLP acts for Blink49 Studios, a new Canadian-controlled studio venture backed by Endeavor Content…
News & Events
-
Entertainment
David Zitzerman at the 2024 Banff World Media Festival
Join David Zitzerman at the 2024 Banff World Media Festival for the Topic Table session "Alternative Canadian Film Financing Structures".The Banff World Media Festival is an international conference… -
Banking and Financial Services
The Canadian Legal Lexpert Directory 2024 Continues to Recognize Goodmans
We are proud to announce Goodmans LLP has once again been recognized in the 2024 edition of The Canadian Legal Lexpert Directory.91 Goodmans lawyers have been recognized as top-tier in their… -
Banking and Financial Services
Who's Who Legal Continues to Recognize Goodmans in the Canada 2023 Guide
We are pleased to share Goodmans lawyers have been recognized across Who's Who Legal's National Guide: Canada 2023. WWL National Guides identify national or regional leaders in a sector, industry…